2025 GMC Canyon vs. Toyota Tacoma: The Best Midsize Truck for Off-Road Adventures

If you’re shopping for a midsize truck that won’t let you down on weekend adventures in the Hudson Valley, two options consistently rise to the top: the 2025 GMC Canyon and Toyota Tacoma. Both deliver solid performance, and both handle off-road duty well, but when it comes to towing power, torque, and effective tech features, the GMC Canyon emerges as the smarter pick. Let our team at Meadowland GMC take you through just why the GMC Canyon is the best midsize truck for the money — and your sense of adventure.

Engine Performance: Power That Makes a Difference

Here’s what sets the 2025 GMC Canyon apart from the start. Every trim gets the same powerful 2.7-liter turbocharged four-cylinder engine, which cranks out 310 horsepower and 430 lb-ft of torque. Whether you go with the base Elevation or the top-of-the-line Denali, you get identical performance — no need to upgrade to enjoy the power you need for merging onto Interstate 684 or tackling steep climbs in the Taconic Mountains.

Toyota takes a different route. The Tacoma’s standard 2.4-liter turbocharged setup makes 278 horsepower and 317 lb-ft of torque — decent numbers, but you’ll feel the difference. To match the Canyon’s torque output, you’ll need Toyota’s hybrid i-FORCE MAX system, which bumps things up to 326 horsepower and 465 lb-ft of torque. Naturally, you’ll pay for that upgrade. The Tacoma edges out the Canyon for fuel economy, with 20 mpg in the city, 26 mpg on the highway, and 23 mpg combined (for two-wheel drive) versus the Canyon’s 19/23/20 mpg, but that efficiency comes at the cost of standard performance.

If you’re looking for the best midsize pickup truck for adventuring, though, here’s where the Canyon really shows its muscle: towing capacity. The Canyon hauls up to 7,700 pounds, while the Tacoma maxes out at 6,500 pounds. That’s a massive 1,200-pound advantage that makes all the difference when you’re pulling a boat to Lake Gleneida or hauling a camping trailer. The Canyon also handles bigger payloads, with a 1,803-pound capacity compared to the Tacoma’s 1,680-pound limit.

Off-Road Capabilities: Built for Adventure

The Canyon AT4 is the standout option when it comes to serious off-road work, with Multimatic jounce control dampers that deliver real results on every kind of terrain. Pair those with front and rear locking differentials and all-terrain tires, and you’ve got a setup that’s ready for anything around the Hudson Highlands. The factory 2-inch lift on all Canyon trims helps keep you rolling wherever you are, and the Denali’s underbody camera is ideal when you’re navigating tight trail situations.

The Toyota Tacoma’s TRD Pro trim fights back with FOX internal bypass shocks and Old Man Emu suspension that combine effectively for technical crawling situations. The Tacoma has the edge on ground clearance, with 10.4 to 11.5 inches against the Canyon’s 9.6 to 10.5 inches, but the Canyon’s advanced suspension technology more than makes up for the gap. Both trucks offer terrain management systems and solid four-wheel-drive setups, but the Canyon AT4’s Multimatic dampers provide better stability when you’re moving quickly over rough ground.

Real-world testing shows each truck’s personality. The GMC Canyon dominates high-speed desert runs thanks to its Baja mode and advanced shock absorbers, while the Toyota Tacoma shines on slow, technical trail challenges with its precise crawl control. For the mixed terrain around Carmel — from rocky Appalachian trails to sandy fire roads — the Canyon’s balanced approach and robust frame with electronic locking differentials give you the versatility you need.

Interior Design and Technology

Climb into the Canyon, and you’ll immediately notice the 11.3-inch touch screen dominating the dashboard. Most Tacoma trims still use smaller 8-inch displays, making the GMC feel more modern right away. The Canyon backs this up with an 11.0-inch digital driver display that keeps navigation and vehicle info where you need it. Wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto work flawlessly, and wireless charging in the AT4 and Denali means no more cable mess.

If you want a little luxury while you explore, the Denali trim offers Jet Black leather seats and teak wood accents for an upscale look and feel. You’ll also stay comfortable with heated and ventilated seats and dual-zone climate control. Toyota does offer more variety in the Tacoma, with 11 different trims to the Canyon’s three, but GMC’s approach lets you enjoy better standard equipment without hunting through endless option packages.

Toyota does some things well with the Tacoma — its rear underseat storage, fold-flat passenger seat, and digital key option are genuinely useful. The Tacoma also gives you more cab choices with XtraCab (two seats) and Double Cab (five seats), while the Canyon only comes in Crew Cab form. Again, though, GMC’s strategy of offering fewer but better-equipped models means you get more advanced tech for your money across the board.

Exterior Design and Functionality

The 2025 Canyon nails the look of a truck that means business but doesn’t sacrifice style. Its bold lines and striking grille show off its practical strength, while the sharp LED lighting and the Denali’s standard 20-inch diamond-cut wheels add polish.

Toyota gives you more bed options, with 60.3-inch and 73.5-inch lengths versus the Canyon’s single 61.7-inch bed. For space and convenience, though, look at the width. The Canyon’s bed measures 58.1 inches across compared to the Tacoma’s 44.7 inches. That extra width makes loading much easier, whether you’re hauling mulch for your garden or adventure gear for weekend trips.

Discover Why the GMC Canyon Leads the Midsize Truck Segment

Ready to see why the GMC Canyon is the best midsize truck of 2025? Head over to Meadowland GMC and experience the complete Canyon lineup firsthand. Our sales team knows what Carmel drivers need and can match you with the right Canyon configuration for your lifestyle and budget, while our finance department can guide you through the practicalities of financing your new truck. Get in touch now to schedule a test-drive and find out more.

Images from gmc.com

Tags: GMC Canyon, GMC Canyon features, GMC Canyon performance, GMC Comparison
Posted in GMC Vehicles | No Comments »