Mar 6, 2025

Carmel, NY, is home to many sweet spots where you can satisfy your cravings. There’s no need to go far to enjoy a treat that’s just as sweet as the town itself. From local bakeries to ice cream parlors, there’s something for every dessert lover. Let’s take a look at some of the best places to satisfy your sweet tooth within a short drive of Carmel.

Pastries in display cabinet

The Baker’s Daughter

The Baker’s Daughter is a must-visit for anyone in Carmel craving artisanal baked goods. Known for their beautiful cakes, pastries, and cookies, this local bakery has been serving up delicious treats for years. Whether you’re stopping in for a fresh batch of cookies or ordering a custom-designed cake for a special occasion, The Baker’s Daughter has you covered. Their signature desserts include everything from light and fluffy cupcakes to decadent cheesecakes, all made with the highest quality ingredients. Each bite is a reminder of why this local favorite is a go-to for many Carmel residents looking for something sweet and special.

Pink Sugar Pastries

If you’re in the mood for a dessert that feels like a little piece of Paris, look no further than Pink Sugar Pastries. This charming bakery offers a variety of French-inspired desserts, including croissants, éclairs, and macarons. Their selection of pastries is perfect for anyone who enjoys the delicate, buttery textures of classic French desserts. You can also find cakes and tarts that are as beautiful as they are delicious. Pink Sugar Pastries is the perfect place to treat yourself to a sophisticated dessert experience that combines elegance and mouthwatering flavor.

The Carmel Creamery

When it comes to ice cream, The Carmel Creamery is a local treasure. This family-owned creamery serves up some of the creamiest and most flavorful ice cream in the area, with a variety of classic and creative flavors. Whether you’re in the mood for a rich chocolate fudge or a fruity sorbet, their ice cream is made fresh daily using only the best ingredients. The Carmel Creamery also offers ice cream cakes and sundaes, making it an excellent stop for any occasion. With its friendly atmosphere and irresistible treats, The Carmel Creamery is a great spot for residents to cool off and indulge.

General Bake Shoppe

For those who love a mix of traditional and innovative flavors, General Bake Shoppe is a must-try. Just a short drive away in Brewster, this spot is known for serving up all your favorite classic baked goods, from buttery croissants to creamy pies. But what sets General Bake Shoppe apart is their ability to combine nostalgic flavors with a modern twist. Their seasonal treats, such as fruit tarts and pumpkin-filled pastries, change throughout the year, offering something new with every visit. If you’re looking for a place where old-fashioned charm meets creative baking, General Bake Shoppe is the perfect choice.

Bliss

Bliss in Mahopac is an exceptional dessert bar and eatery that specializes in indulgent sweet treats, perfect for anyone with a serious sweet tooth. From their signature ice cream sundaes to delicious baked goods, Bliss offers a menu full of mouthwatering options. One standout is their extensive list of milkshakes, which come with all kinds of fun toppings like whipped cream, sprinkles, and even cookies. It’s the ideal spot for a relaxed afternoon with friends or a celebratory treat after a long day. Bliss is a sweet escape for anyone in the Carmel area looking to satisfy their cravings for something indulgent and over-the-top.

Scoops ‘N More

For a fun and family-friendly dessert destination, Scoops ‘N More is a great choice. Located nearby, this ice cream parlor serves up a wide variety of ice cream flavors, ranging from traditional to unique seasonal selections. But it’s not just about ice cream – they also offer a selection of frozen yogurt, sundaes, milkshakes, and even waffle cones made fresh on-site. With a fun atmosphere and delicious treats, Scoops ‘N More is the perfect spot for families to stop by after a day of exploring Carmel. Their seasonal flavors and customizable sundaes make each visit feel like a special occasion.

A Sweet Treat Awaits You in Carmel

From The Baker’s Daughter’s custom cakes to the ice cream delights of The Carmel Creamery, Carmel, NY, is home to some incredible dessert spots that cater to every craving. Whether you’re looking for a sophisticated pastry, a rich gelato, or a classic donut, the desserts around Carmel won’t disappoint. With so many local gems to choose from, it’s easy to satisfy your sweet tooth with a quick trip to one of these delightful spots. After indulging in a delicious treat, don’t forget to visit Meadowland GMC for all your automotive needs. They’re here to help make sure your next dessert run is in style!

Image Credit: Pastries in display cabinet by Natalia Y., licensed by Unsplash License