May 20, 2025

There’s nothing quite like a plate full of crispy, juicy wings to kick off a great night out. Whether you like them mild or extra spicy, wings are a go-to comfort food for many of us in Carmel, NY. Luckily, Carmel and the surrounding area offer plenty of delicious spots to grab a plate of wings, each with its own twist. If you’re wondering where to get the best wings in the area, look no further. Here are some of the top places to satisfy your wing cravings around Carmel, NY.

Savory chicken on plate

McCarthy’s

McCarthy’s in Carmel is a classic local spot for enjoying some of the best wings around. Whether you’re in the mood for traditional or boneless wings, McCarthy’s has a wide range of flavors to choose from. From spicy buffalo to tangy barbecue and even garlic parmesan, the wings here are packed with flavor. What sets McCarthy’s apart is its laid-back, friendly atmosphere, perfect for hanging out with friends while you enjoy your meal. Plus, their daily specials and drink pairings make it a great spot to spend an afternoon or evening with great food, drinks, and even better company. (McCarthy’s Website)

La Famiglia Grill

La Famiglia Grill offers an upscale dining experience with a comforting twist. While they’re best known for their authentic Italian dishes, their wings are a must-try. La Famiglia’s wings are expertly cooked to crispy perfection and come in several different flavors, including spicy buffalo and tangy BBQ. What makes their wings unique is their combination of flavors, which are subtly influenced by their Italian roots. You can even pair your wings with one of their fine wines for the perfect dining experience. Whether you’re coming in for a cozy dinner or a quick bite, La Famiglia Grill delivers on flavor and quality. (La Famiglia Grill Website)

Tavern on 52

Tavern on 52 in Garrison is a great spot for anyone who’s craving delicious wings in a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere. Their wings are known for being crispy on the outside and tender on the inside, with just the right balance of heat and flavor. From classic buffalo to garlic and honey mustard, Tavern on 52 offers a variety of wing options that are perfect for pairing with their craft beers. The cozy, rustic environment makes this place an excellent choice for unwinding after a long day or enjoying a weekend out. Whether you’re there for a quick snack or a full meal, their wings will definitely leave you satisfied. (Tavern on 52 Website)

Three Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria

Three Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria in nearby Mahopac offers a fantastic mix of pizza and wings that are sure to please anyone’s appetite. Their wings are always a hit, with an array of sauces to choose from, including classic buffalo, sweet BBQ, and even hot honey. What sets Three Brothers apart is their commitment to freshness and quality. Their wings are cooked to perfection and always served hot and crispy. Pair them with one of their signature pizzas for a delicious meal that’s perfect for any occasion. If you’re in the Mahopac area and craving wings, Three Brothers is definitely worth the visit. (Three Brothers Restaurant Website)

Bliss

Bliss in Mahopac offers a unique twist on traditional wings, featuring bold flavors that will excite your taste buds. Their wings are perfectly cooked, offering a crispy texture with a melt-in-your-mouth interior. Bliss specializes in creative wing options like spicy honey mustard and sriracha lime, making them stand out from the usual wing joints. The laid-back atmosphere of Bliss makes it a great place to hang out and enjoy some tasty wings with friends or family. If you’re looking to try something a little different and love bold flavors, Bliss is the place for you. (Bliss Website)

The Iron Horse Grill

If you’re heading to Cold Spring, be sure to stop by The Iron Horse Grill, a fantastic spot to grab wings while enjoying a welcoming pub atmosphere. Known for their delicious pub food, The Iron Horse Grill serves up wings that are crispy, flavorful, and packed with sauce options. From traditional buffalo to more adventurous flavors like teriyaki and bourbon BBQ, the wings here are perfect for satisfying all kinds of cravings. The relaxed vibe and friendly service make this place a favorite among locals and visitors alike. If you’re in the area, don’t miss out on their tasty wings and great drink specials. (The Iron Horse Grill Website)

The Barn at Bedford Hills

The Barn at Bedford Hills offers a wonderful happy hour, and their wings are one of the highlights of the menu. Known for their fresh ingredients and homemade sauces, The Barn’s wings are a local favorite. Whether you like them extra hot or mild and smoky, they have something for everyone. The rustic setting, with its charming barn atmosphere, creates a cozy spot to enjoy wings with a craft beer. You can also pair your wings with some of their delicious sides, like loaded fries or a fresh salad, for a well-rounded meal. (The Barn at Bedford Hills Website)

Grab a Bite in Carmel

No matter where you are in Carmel, NY, or the surrounding areas, there’s no shortage of delicious places to grab a plate of wings. From cozy local spots like McCarthy’s and La Famiglia Grill to the inventive flavors at Bliss and Three Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria, Carmel has you covered. So, next time you’re craving wings, head to one of these local favorites for a flavorful experience. Don’t forget to check out Meadowland GMC if you’re in the market for a new vehicle!

Image Credit: Savory chicken on plate by Atharva Tulsi, licensed by Unsplash License